Ex-GOP chair under fire - Tip of the Ice Burg
Ex-GOP chair under fire
Donna Schalansky denies critics’ accusations of fiscal wrongdoing in county post
By Stan Oklobdzija - Bee Staff Writer
Published 12:00 am PDT Sunday, April 22, 2007
Story appeared in METRO section, Page B1
The resignation of former Sacramento County Republican Party Chairwoman Donna Schalansky has become the flash point in an internal party battle that centers on whether thousands of dollars of reimbursements she received were in violation of state law.
Schalansky said her March 8 resignation was unrelated to questions regarding the expenses and that any allegations of wrongdoing are a ploy by dissidents who have tried and failed to take control of the party.
“My reason for resigning is simple, but very personal and family-related, and I don’t care to discuss it with the press,” Schalansky wrote in an e-mail.
But some in the party, including a former treasurer, say mounting pressure about her financial practices, brought by a conservative faction of the party, led to Schalansky stepping down.
“She got caught with her hand in the cookie jar,” said Jay Evans, who served 18 months as the party’s treasurer and is part of the self-described conservative camp.
Evans said he based his accusation on disclosure forms on file with the secretary of state’s office and his own experience as treasurer, and that he and at least one other party member have brought their concerns to the attention of the state Fair Political Practices Commission.
State law requires information about “third-party payees” be disclosed for reimbursements of $500 or more. But financial disclosure forms filed with the secretary of state’s office show Schalansky received 29 payments of $500 or more — a total of $35,922 — between 2003 and 2006 without receipts showing who received the payments for which she was reimbursed.
Tom Scott, the party’s current treasurer, said receipts for third-party vendors were on file as far back as 1991, but denied The Bee’s request to review them.
Scott said the receipts are available to all Sacramento County Republican Central Committee members. But Evans and Jeff Allen, a committee member for five years and another member of the conservative group, both said their requests to see the receipts have been denied.
The reimbursements — as well as $27,000 the party paid to Schalansky for political consulting — became an issue in the party’s recent selection of a new chair.
One e-mail circulated among members and provided to The Bee said Schalansky retired under a “cloud of mismanagement.” It criticized then-acting Chairman Craig MacGlashan because he had not allowed a panel, formed to audit Schalansky’s finances, to do its job.
MacGlashan said the panel was not formed to audit Schalansky’s finances, but to decide on general fiscal policies and practices for the party’s future. He declined to comment about anything the committee has done since its formation.
On April 12, MacGlashan fended off a challenge from Craig DeLuz, who was supported by Schalansky’s critics, to win the chairmanship of the central committee.
Schalansky was chairwoman for 12 years. Her daughter, Amber Schalansky-Fretwell, who served as second vice chairwoman, also resigned. The resignations became effective April 2.
According to Form 460 documents overseen by the FPPC, Schalansky’s reimbursements of $500 or more included a cumulative $12,256 for office supplies and $11,185 for literature.
Violations of the law requiring a third-party recipient on reimbursements of $500 or more can carry a penalty of up to $5,000 per occurrence, said FPPC spokeswoman Whitney Barazoto. She said the FPPC would neither confirm nor deny an investigation of Schalansky or the Sacramento County Republican Party.
Evans and others critics charge that Schalansky had a free hand with the party’s checkbook and used it to reward herself.
Schalansky and current party leaders say that is nonsense. Scott, the current treasurer, said all expenditures are approved by either the executive committee or the full committee, depending on the dollar amount.
But Allen said that “none of (Schalansky’s) expenses were explicitly made or voted on as a body. … She had never brought forth the fact that she was going to pay herself for any services whatsoever.”
Evans, who as treasurer served on the executive committee, was more blunt.
“It doesn’t happen,” he said. “To the best of my knowledge, I’ve never seen an expense come to me other than the (biennial) budget.”
Evans said that when he was elected the party’s treasurer in January 2003, he found “the treasurer is not allowed to be a treasurer in the conventional sense.”
He said he was not allowed access to the party’s finances. He said only Schalansky and Executive Director Karen Atteberry, a paid employee, were allowed access to the checking accounts, and one of his only duties was to read at meetings a monthly report prepared by Atteberry.
“A lot of us for so many years put our blind faith in (Schalansky) for the superb leader we thought her to be,” he said.
Atteberry did not respond to phone calls and e-mails seeking comment.
Schalansky, in an e-mail, said the criticisms of her are just sour grapes by Evans, Allen and their conservative faction.
“In politics, as in many other aspects of life, one doesn’t always win the battles they fight,” she said. “This is certainly the case between Mr. Evans and me. Unfortunately, this time he has chosen this method as a means to vent his anger toward me.”
Schalansky said she is not concerned about any possible investigation or appearance of impropriety, because “all activities are reported to the County Central Committee in regular treasurer reports as well as properly disclosed with the Secretary of State.”
The central committee currently has 31 members who were elected from the five county supervisorial districts. Also, Republican elected officials who represent part of Sacramento can serve on the committee or appoint a member. There currently are 13 of these ex-officio members, making a total of 44 members.
The committee meets monthly and is charged with supporting Republican candidates and advancing party issues.